Current:Home > NewsScience Day at COP27 Shows That Climate Talks Aren’t Keeping Pace With Planetary Physics -FutureWise Finance
Science Day at COP27 Shows That Climate Talks Aren’t Keeping Pace With Planetary Physics
View
Date:2025-04-18 15:59:56
The first week of climate talks at COP27 ended with another sharp warning from scientists, who said that global warming is already killing thousands to tens of thousands of people each year, and that the carnage will only increase without immediate, sharp cuts of the emissions heating the climate.
The reported death toll “is probably an underestimate because it is based on preliminary quantification for heat-related mortality,” said Kristie Ebi, a public health researcher at the University of Washington and co-author of a new report released at the United Nations climate conference in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt. “The total number would be larger if all climate-sensitive health outcomes were considered for which there is attribution to climate change,” she said.
The scientific evidence shows that global warming impacts are outrunning the slow pace of negotiations aimed at slowing climate change, said co-author Johan Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research.
“You cannot continue compromising with science all the time,” he said. “You cannot negotiate with the planet, you cannot negotiate with the atmosphere. These are physical limits. And you’re simply hurting yourself if you underestimate the power of the Earth system.”
That may hold especially with plans to adapt to the effects of global warming with measures like adequate residential cooling, or sea walls. It’s time to “question the myth of endless adaptation,” the authors wrote. “People and ecosystems in different places across the world are already confronted with limits to adaptation, and if the planet warms beyond 1.5°C or even 2°C, more widespread breaching of adaptation limits is expected. Hence, adaptation efforts cannot be a substitute for ambitious mitigation.”
That doesn’t mean giving up on efforts to adapt to the impacts of climate change, said Simon Stiell, executive secretary of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. He said there needs to be more focus on proactive measures to protect people, “But they will not prevent all losses and damage that we have seen. Investing in mitigation is a way of reducing the need to invest in adaptation and resilience.”
The “myth of endless adaptation” really goes to the heart of the findings of one of the most recent reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which pointed out “large knowledge gaps” about how to adapt to the changing climate, said Aditi Mukherji, with the International Water Management Institute.
“We do not know which adaptation is effective in reducing risk and under what context,” she said. “And whatever we know about the effectiveness of adaptation, at higher levels of global warming it is pretty certain that those adaptation measures will not remain very effective.”
Adaptation Gap Grows Wider
A key area where adaptation efforts are falling far short is in addressing the health impacts of global warming, Ebi said.
“Under the UNFCCC’s adaptation funds, less than half of 1 percent goes to health,” she said. “To be able to effectively increase resilience, and to reduce vulnerability, we have to have human health and well-being at the heart of the negotiations.”
The Covid-19 pandemic showed that “our health systems are really unprepared for shocks and stresses,” she said. “Climate change is a massive shock and stress that’s already affecting many countries, requiring health investments where we take into account not just human health, but animal health, nature, and all of the other drivers that affect our health and our well being.”
Investments now should be focused on cutting down the number of preventable deaths from projected impacts like extreme heat and vector-borne diseases, she added.
The report highlights “vulnerability clusters” in Central America, North Africa’s Sahel, Central and East Africa, the Middle East and across Asia, where 1.6 billion people are threatened by climate-driven hazards. That number “could double in the coming years,” said Mercedes Bustamante, an ecologist at the University of Brasilia.
Breakdowns or big shifts in monsoon rains and intensification of ocean currents are increasing “human vulnerability in densely populated coastal areas,” she said. Focusing on vulnerability hotspots can prioritize action areas in the context of the “loss and damage” discussions occurring at COP27, she added, referring to those funds paid by rich nations most responsible for warming the planet to poorer nations suffering disproportionately from heat, drought, flooding and other extreme weather events linked to climate change.
The report says the international community must recognize a “planetary imperative” in the fact that the greatest harms of global warming are falling on undeveloped countries that have done the least to cause it, while the wealthy nations responsible for the vast majority of climate-warming emissions bear fewer of the worst impacts. Mukherji said new attribution science linking climate change and its destructive impacts “helps in the cause for furthering the loss and damage agenda” at COP27.
“It is allowing us to [identify] the fingerprint of climate change in a disaster or a hazard,” she said. “That really helps quantify loss and damages related to climate change much better.”
That can lead to better use and distribution of funding, she said.
The report concluded that climate mobility should also be high on the laundry list for COP delegates because “Involuntary migration and displacement will increasingly occur due to climate change-related slow-onset impacts and the rising frequency and intensity of extreme weather events.”
At the same time, climate impacts disproportionately result in “particularly poor and marginalized communities losing their capacity to adapt by moving away,” with no option but to stay and face increasing climate threats.
Despite knowledge gaps, the scientists said becoming resilient to global warming impacts requires getting out of the response mode and widely adopting an anticipatory approach, like strengthening shelters on an ongoing basis, preparing to harvest crops early and temporarily evacuating, which can reduce the chances for prolonged displacement.
Making those preparations, Rockström said, requires inclusive decision-making.
“A lot of the social sciences are, not surprisingly, showing how we need to get to local scales, local needs, local communities, and multiple stakeholders engaged to have any chance of robust climate policy implementation,” he said.
The new report was compiled by several independent science and science advocacy organizations—The Earth League, Future Earth and the World Climate Research Programme. All these 10 of the bullet points in the report are interconnected, and a deep understanding of the complexities should be “central to the climate negotiations,” Rockström said. “Human security requires climate security.”
veryGood! (7931)
Related
- 'As foretold in the prophecy': Elon Musk and internet react as Tesla stock hits $420 all
- Sheriff suspends bid for US House seat once held by ex-Speaker McCarthy
- US Olympic track and field trials: Winners and losers from final 4 days
- Over 300 earthquakes detected in Hawaii; Kilauea volcano not yet erupting
- Why members of two of EPA's influential science advisory committees were let go
- Some Gen Xers can start dipping into retirement savings without penalty, but should you?
- Much of New Mexico is under flood watch after 100 rescued from waters over weekend
- Sydney McLaughlin-Levrone dominates 400 hurdles, sets world record again
- Tree trimmer dead after getting caught in wood chipper at Florida town hall
- The Karen Read murder case ends in a mistrial. Prosecutors say they will try again
Ranking
- US appeals court rejects Nasdaq’s diversity rules for company boards
- Are banks, post offices, UPS and FedEx open on July 4th? Here's what to know
- Krispy Kreme giving away free doughnuts, iced coffee two days a week in July: How to get the deal
- Nelly Korda withdraws from London tournament after being bitten by a dog
- Could your smelly farts help science?
- Chipotle preps for Olympics by offering meals of star athletes, gold foil-wrapped burritos
- “Always go out on top”: Texas A&M Chancellor John Sharp will retire June 2025
- Pennsylvania man killed when fireworks explode in his garage
Recommendation
John Galliano out at Maison Margiela, capping year of fashion designer musical chairs
Hurricane Beryl maps show path and landfall forecast
US Olympic track and field trials: Winners and losers from final 4 days
Connie the container dog dies months after Texas rescue: 'She was such a fighter'
Woman dies after Singapore family of 3 gets into accident in Taiwan
Fifty Shades of Grey's Jamie Dornan Reveals Texts With Costar Dakota Johnson
How can you be smarter with your money? Follow these five tips
Authorities say 13-year-old armed with replica handgun fatally shot by police after chase in upstate New York